Retain vs Extract

The $500k question: extract it all, retain it all, or draw only what you need — compounded over your horizon.

★ CHAPTER BRIEF

Take $500,000 of corporate profit personally and roughly $223,000 disappears in tax before the first dollar is invested. Retain it and the corporation keeps $444,000 working. The realistic answer is the middle path: extract what your life actually costs, and let every surplus dollar compound in the lower-tax environment.

The Success Trap is a habit: draw everything out each year because that is what feeling successful looks like. This simulator runs the same profit three ways — extract it all, retain it all, and the book’s recommended discipline of withdrawing only the need — then compounds each residue over your horizon.

Retention is not the end of the story: retained dollars face a second tax on eventual extraction, and invested passively they generate AAII. The point of the comparison is the size of the head start — a head start the later chapters teach you to protect (portfolio design) and extract efficiently (CDA, IPP, drawdown sequencing).

★ KEY POINT
The tax deferred by retention is an interest-free loan from the CRA, invested for your benefit until you extract. The longer the horizon, the more the loan is worth.
⚠ WARNING
Retained values shown are pre-extraction — do not read them as spendable. And idle retained cash triggers the passive-income grind above $50,000 of AAII. Retention is step one; deployment is the strategy.
Loading the calculator…

Get your full PDF report

Your inputs, your results narrated in plain English, and the questions to bring to your advisor — sent securely to a verified email. We’ll text you a code first; requesting a report does not create an advisor–client relationship.

Request an advisor match

Questions to ask your advisor

Ask your CPA

What did my personal draw actually cost in combined tax last year, versus what my lifestyle required?

Ask your CPA

What is our plan for the second tax — how do retained dollars eventually come out?

Ask your Advisor

How are the retained dollars invested, and what AAII do they generate?

Continue in book order

Educational illustration, not advice. This tool is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, legal, accounting, or insurance advice. Results are estimates, not promises — hypothetical illustrations are projections only. Figures use Ontario rates as of the date stamped above; rates and limits change. Confirm current figures and your specific situation with a CPA, tax lawyer, and licensed insurance advisor before acting.