COLI vs Taxable Portfolio

Exempt growth, the CDA credit, and what carrier illustrations really promise (and don’t) — anchored to the book’s July 2026 illustration.

★ CHAPTER BRIEF

On the book’s carrier illustration (male 45, non-smoker, $100,000 × 10 years), corporately-owned participating whole life projects a $7,061,352 death benefit at 85 on the current scale — $2,285,925 guaranteed. Growth inside the exempt policy generates zero AAII while alive, and the death benefit less ACB credits the CDA for tax-free distribution.

COLI attacks both corporate tax problems at once: the annual ~50% drag on passive income (exempt growth isn’t taxed annually) and the grind (exempt growth isn’t AAII). At death, the ACB has decayed toward zero, so nearly the entire benefit passes through the CDA tax-free — the corporate dollar’s cleanest exit.

The honest test is the one this page runs: the same deposits in a taxable corporate portfolio, compounded with real drag, versus the illustrated and guaranteed columns. The gap is usually large — and so is the gap between the current scale and the guarantee. Both numbers belong in the decision.

★ KEY POINT
Insurance is bought with health as much as money. Underwriting comes first — the structure conversation is worthless if the insurability isn’t there.
⚠ WARNING
Illustrations are not promises. Dividend scales change; the book’s own example shows a $4.8M swing between current scale and guaranteed. Do not treat projected death-benefit ranges as promises, and never buy for the projection alone — the guaranteed column must still make sense for you.
Loading the calculator…

Get your full PDF report

Your inputs, your results narrated in plain English, and the questions to bring to your advisor — sent securely to a verified email. We’ll text you a code first; requesting a report does not create an advisor–client relationship.

Request an advisor match

Questions to ask your advisor

Ask your Insurance

Show me the guaranteed column first, then current scale and scale −1% — and this comparison against a taxable portfolio on my numbers.

Ask your CPA

How would premiums flow on my T2, and who files the T2054 when capital dividends are eventually paid?

Ask your Tax counsel

Does the corporate ownership structure (Opco vs Holdco) put the policy or the CDA at risk?

Continue in book order

Educational illustration, not advice. This tool is provided for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, legal, accounting, or insurance advice. Results are estimates, not promises — hypothetical illustrations are projections only. Figures use Ontario rates as of the date stamped above; rates and limits change. Confirm current figures and your specific situation with a CPA, tax lawyer, and licensed insurance advisor before acting.